Criterion |
Excellent |
Good |
Fair |
Poor |
Correctness (10) |
All components are completely correct. (10) |
At least one component contains a minor error.
(7-9) |
At least one component contains a major error.
(4-6) |
Multiple major errors, or an entirely incorrect
response. (0-3) |
Precision (5) |
No meaningful ambiguity. (5) |
Occasional or minor issues of precision, causing
meaningful ambiguity that can be overcome by charitable interpretation by the
reader. (3/4) |
Major precision errors that cause meaningful ambiguity
in the interpretation of the solution, which can only be resolved with
difficulty if at all. (2) |
Severely underspecified instructions, definitions,
claims, or arguments. (0/1) |
Clarity (5) |
All components are clear, organized, and easy to follow.
(5) |
Occasional or minor issues of clarity, causing confusion
that can be overcome by careful reading and charitable interpretation by the
reader. (3/4) |
Truly confusing writing that can only be interpreted
with significant effort. (2) |
Exceedingly confusing writing. (0/1) |