You will be presenting a paper. Beyond the particular topic of this class, we will aim to develop our ability to understand and present papers, as follows.
Something that students often find challenging and struggle with is to understand and communicate at a high-level. Make this your first goal. Specifically, aim to start with a 10-minute distillation of the paper in which you provide useful high-level information. This would include the contribution of the paper, its novelty, its impact, and your critiques of all these. Think about the points you want to make and strive to remove any details that are not necessary to make those points. This high-level overview should be understandable to a relative non-expert.
The second step is an in-depth look. Your goal is to distill the paper, to capture and represent this paper in an accessible and comprehensive way. This can (and often does) involve effectively redoing the paper on your own, in part because papers are not all well written and in part because this is the best way to understand the paper. Change the notation and language to fit our context and the style of (say) CSE207A. Recast the algorithms, possibly in different and better notation. Ask how you can simplify. Ways include to present a special case, make some simplifying assumptions, work out an example and work with it throughout.
A good understanding and presentation may require looking at other papers. It will require making choices. For example, there may be certain details into which you cannot, or do not want to, enter, for various reasons, including that the paper is inscrutable. That's OK, but, if so, you should indicate this, indicate choices you have made, and give a high-level sense of what the paper is trying to do.
Prepare well, and have a plan. Create a set of notes that you can hand out to the class before your presentation. You can use either slides or the whiteboard. If you use slides, their copy can serve as the notes you hand out, and you may find preparation easier.
Explicitly evaluate the paper along the dimensions we have suggested for the course, meaning methods, applications, security and society. Consider the questions there, and see what answers are possible. These answers may not be in the paper. It will be up to you and our class discussion to come up with perspectives.
Sometimes, a student will just hold a copy of the paper and try to copy stuff down from it onto the whiteboard. This is not likely to yield a good presentation. As above, distill and recast the paper, put it in your own notation and words, and base your presentation on your notes rather than directly copying from the paper. Of course refer to the paper as needed.
Papers can be ambiguous, have poor notation and have mistakes. Don't see the paper as a bible. Redo it. You can change things, use different notation, even change the algorithms.
Think critically about the paper. Evaluate each paper you present in light of the different dimensions we have discussed, namely methods, applications, security, society. Your notes and presentation should explicitly consider and discuss each of these dimensions for the work you are presenting.
Beyond your own presentation, the expectation is that you participate in discussions of presentations made by others. This includes critiques of the ideas and trying to go further.