<?php
/*
  Copyright (C) 2003, 2004 Dana Dahlstrom
  (http://www.cs.ucsd.edu/users/ddahlstr/) and Vinu Somayaji
  (http://www.cs.ucsd.edu/users/vsomayaj/).

  This file is part of Semiotics and UID.

  Semiotics and UID is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify
  it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
  the Free Software Foundation; either version 2 of the License, or
  (at your option) any later version.

  Semiotics and UID is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
  but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
  MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
  GNU General Public License for more details.

  You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
  along with Semiotics and UID; if not, write to the Free Software
  Foundation, Inc., 59 Temple Place, Suite 330, Boston, MA  02111-1307  USA
*/

/* Include common functions */
require('common.php');

/* Print page header */
print_page_header('Saussurean Semiotics');
?>
<h1>Saussurean Semiotics</h1>

<p><img src="images/saussure.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Saussure"
align="left" hspace="10" vspace="10" />Where Charles Saunders <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Peirce" title="Look up: Peirce" onclick="show_term('Peirce', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Peirce</a>
took a logical perspective in
what he called "<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=semiotics" title="Look up: semiotics" onclick="show_term('semiotics', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">semiotics</a>", attempting to establish a "formal doctrine of
<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signs</a>", Swiss linguist Ferdinand de <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Saussure" title="Look up: Saussure" onclick="show_term('Saussure', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Saussure</a>
(1857-1913) viewed what he called "<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=semiology" title="Look up: semiology" onclick="show_term('semiology', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">semiology</a>" as "a science which studies
the role of signs as part of social life". The term "semiotics" is now generally
applied to Saussure's work as well, recognizing the substantial similarity
between what the two theorists were trying to achieve.</p>

<a style="clear: both;" name="model"></a><h2>Saussure's model of the sign</h2>

<p>One contrast between <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Peirce" title="Look up: Peirce" onclick="show_term('Peirce', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Peirce</a> and <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Saussure" title="Look up: Saussure" onclick="show_term('Saussure', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Saussure</a> is in their models of
the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a>. Peirce's model is triadic while Saussure's is dyadic, having
two parts instead of three:</p>

<ul>
  <li>a <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signifier" title="Look up: signifier" onclick="show_term('signifier', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signifier</a>, the form of the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a>; and</li>
  <li>a <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signified" title="Look up: signified" onclick="show_term('signified', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signified</a>, the concept it represents.</li>
</ul>

<p><a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Saussure" title="Look up: Saussure" onclick="show_term('Saussure', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Saussure</a> thought of both the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signifier" title="Look up: signifier" onclick="show_term('signifier', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signifier</a> and the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signified" title="Look up: signified" onclick="show_term('signified', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signified</a>
as purely psychological phenomena, with any connections to the physical world
presumably mediated through the sensorimotor system of the interpreter. Later
thinkers have used the term "signifier" also to refer to the material form of a
<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a>, like <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Peirce" title="Look up: Peirce" onclick="show_term('Peirce', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Peirce's</a> <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=representamen" title="Look up: representamen" onclick="show_term('representamen', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">representamen</a>. The
relationship between signifier and signified is called <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signification" title="Look up: signification" onclick="show_term('signification', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signification</a>, and
together they constitute a sign.</p>

<p>One point worth mentioning is that a particular <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a> consists of the
combination of <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signifier" title="Look up: signifier" onclick="show_term('signifier', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signifier</a> and <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signified" title="Look up: signified" onclick="show_term('signified', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signified</a>; when either part is
changed, the whole becomes a different sign. Thus when the "Enter" key signifies
the end of a line of text, that is one sign; but when it is used to confirm a
dialog, that is a different sign.</p>

<p>Notice that the interpretation of <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signifier" title="Look up: signifier" onclick="show_term('signifier', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signifiers</a> as
material forms conveniently allows us to speak of user interface devices and
display elements directly as signifiers, rather than having to continually (and
awkwardly) refer to their psychological effects on users. <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Saussure" title="Look up: Saussure" onclick="show_term('Saussure', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Saussure's</a> way of thinking, though, usefully draws attention to the fact
that <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signification" title="Look up: signification" onclick="show_term('signification', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signification</a> ultimately depends on perceptions, not merely on
physical form. We should keep this in mind when designing interfaces, since not
all users will perceive things the same way. Some users may not have the
experience or sensory capacity necessary to make certain perceptual
distinctions, and some may not receive certain sensory input at all. A color-
blind person, for example, may have no access to the connotation of "warning"
implied by the use of red as opposed to green in an interface element.</p>

<p>The nature of <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Saussure" title="Look up: Saussure" onclick="show_term('Saussure', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Saussure's</a> <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signified" title="Look up: signified" onclick="show_term('signified', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signified</a> as a mental
concept, not a thing in the world, points to another important distinction,
between what a user thinks a <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a> means and what the designer intended it
to mean. For example, a user entering a value into a text field might think a
press of the "Enter" key signifies an action like "submit" when in fact it
merely signifies the end of the line (or vice-versa). It is incumbent upon
designers of user interfaces to prevent this kind of error when possible, and to
anticipate and gracefully handle errors that aren't prevented.</p>

<p>Within <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Saussure" title="Look up: Saussure" onclick="show_term('Saussure', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Saussure's</a> model it is easy to conceptualize
chains of <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signification" title="Look up: signification" onclick="show_term('signification', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signification</a>: the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signified" title="Look up: signified" onclick="show_term('signified', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signified</a> of one <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a> simply
becomes the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signifier" title="Look up: signifier" onclick="show_term('signifier', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signifier</a> of another. For example, an error message that
reads "No such file" directly signifies that no file exists with the name the
user just entered; this fact might signify that the user made a typographical
error, or perhaps that the file has been deleted. Generally, the fewer levels of
indirection the user must traverse, the better. Naturally, software is limited
in its ability to determine what the user did wrong, because to do so generally
requires knowing the user's intention. Nevertheless, in many cases sensitive
designers can improve the situation by providing more useful feedback.</p>

<a name="structuralism"></a><h2>Sign systems and structuralism</h2>

<p>According to <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Saussure" title="Look up: Saussure" onclick="show_term('Saussure', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Saussure</a>, chains of <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=signification" title="Look up: signification" onclick="show_term('signification', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signification</a> are the ordinary
state of affairs: <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signs</a> usually refer to other signs, not to
physical objects. For him, meaning is relational as opposed to referential; that
is, signs make sense only within a system of related signs, not because of their
inherent properties or their reference to material things.</p>

<p>In a typical <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=GUI" title="Look up: GUI" onclick="show_term('GUI', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">GUI</a>, for example, a file name signifies a file, but
realistically a file is merely another <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a>. Any reference to the
physical world is quite indirect, through many other signs at different levels:
file system organization, its underlying implementation, and so on down to bits,
which are themselves abstract and represented variously as the states of
transistors or magnetic storage media. Of course, the user doesn't need to know
all these details to understand and use files, which is precisely the point: the
relations within the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign_system" title="Look up: sign system" onclick="show_term('sign_system', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign system</a> of the user interface are of primary
concern, not the connection to material reality.</p>

<p><a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=structuralism" title="Look up: structuralism" onclick="show_term('structuralism', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Structuralism</a> is the tradition, beginning with
<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Saussure" title="Look up: Saussure" onclick="show_term('Saussure', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Saussure</a>, of viewing <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signs</a> as functioning within
systems, and analyzing the structure of these systems by identifying their
constituent parts and the relations among them. This outlook has widely informed
study in the humanities and social sciences, beginning with linguistics and
extending to literature, anthropology, and sociology, and other fields. The
influence of structuralism is so widespread that some view it as the basis for
all of <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=semiotics" title="Look up: semiotics" onclick="show_term('semiotics', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">semiotics</a>, or even as synonymous with it.</p>
<?php
/* Print page footer */
print_page_footer();
?>
