REVIEWERS' COMMENTS ---------------------------------------------- REVIEW NO. 1 Comments to the authors: It is suggested to the authors to develop in more detail the conclusions (aspects related to datasets used, the relationships used, etc). ---------------------------------------------- REVIEW NO. 2 Comments to the authors: The authors aim to model complex relationships between products, using data based on co-purchase and co-browsing behavior. They developed a method based on pairwise ranking and embedding learning to build representations of items based on the co-purchasing and cobrowsing statistics. As the title says, it is better to show real recommendation data. ---------------------------------------------- REVIEW NO. 3 Comments to the authors: The paper is well written and conveys results from an interesting study about recommender systems. The abstract can be improved to proved key summary of results in few lines.