<?php
/*
  Copyright (C) 2003, 2004 Dana Dahlstrom
  (http://www.cs.ucsd.edu/users/ddahlstr/) and Vinu Somayaji
  (http://www.cs.ucsd.edu/users/vsomayaj/).

  This file is part of Semiotics and UID.

  Semiotics and UID is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify
  it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
  the Free Software Foundation; either version 2 of the License, or
  (at your option) any later version.

  Semiotics and UID is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
  but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
  MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
  GNU General Public License for more details.

  You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
  along with Semiotics and UID; if not, write to the Free Software
  Foundation, Inc., 59 Temple Place, Suite 330, Boston, MA  02111-1307  USA
*/

/* Include common functions */
require('common.php');

/* Print page header */
print_page_header('Peircian Semiotics');
?>
<h1>Peircian Semiotics</h1>

<p><img src="images/peirce.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="Peirce"
align="left" hspace="10" vspace="10" />Charles Sanders <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Peirce" title="Look up: Peirce" onclick="show_term('Peirce', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Peirce</a>
(1839-1914), the American philosopher,
logician, and scientist (among other things), coined the term "<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=semiotics" title="Look up: semiotics" onclick="show_term('semiotics', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">semiotics</a>
", and introduced several of its fundamental concepts. Peirce (pronounced
"purse"&#8212;the family name was earlier spelled "Pers") declared that anything
can be a <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a>&#8212;words, images, odors, objects, ...
<em>anything</em>&#8212;so long as someone, in some situation, interprets it as
standing for something other than itself. In other words, by themselves, these
<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=token" title="Look up: token" onclick="show_term('token', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">tokens</a> have no meaning; they are given meaning (and thereby
become signs) only when they are interpreted as such. Of Peirce's ideas, the
most relevant to <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=UID" title="Look up: UID" onclick="show_term('UID', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">UID</a> are his model of the sign (the
<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=semiotic_triad" title="Look up: semiotic triad" onclick="show_term('semiotic_triad', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">semiotic triad</a>), and his system of classification of signs (based on how
they convey meaning).</p>

<a style="clear: both;" name="triad"></a><h2>The semiotic triad</h2>

<p>The parts of <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Peirce" title="Look up: Peirce" onclick="show_term('Peirce', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Peirce's</a> triadic model of the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a>
are:</p>

<ul>
  <li>a <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=representamen" title="Look up: representamen" onclick="show_term('representamen', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">representamen</a>, the (not necessarily physical) form of the
  <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a>;</li>
  <li>an <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=interpretant" title="Look up: interpretant" onclick="show_term('interpretant', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">interpretant</a>, the sense made of the sign in the mind of the
  observer (this can be another sign); and</li>
  <li>an <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=object" title="Look up: object" onclick="show_term('object', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">object</a>, that to which the sign refers.</li>
</ul>

<p><img src="images/semiosis.gif" width="208" height="208" alt=
"The process of semiosis" align="left" hspace="10" vspace="10" />These three
parts are together known as the
"<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=semiotic_triad" title="Look up: semiotic triad" onclick="show_term('semiotic_triad', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">semiotic triad</a>", and together they form a <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a>. As mentioned
before, meaning is not directly attached to the sign; instead, it is mediated
through the interaction between the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=representamen" title="Look up: representamen" onclick="show_term('representamen', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">representamen</a>, <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=interpretant" title="Look up: interpretant" onclick="show_term('interpretant', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">interpretant</a>,
and <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=object" title="Look up: object" onclick="show_term('object', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">object</a>. <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Peirce" title="Look up: Peirce" onclick="show_term('Peirce', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Peirce</a> referred to this as the process of
"<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=semiosis" title="Look up: semiosis" onclick="show_term('semiosis', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">semiosis</a>". The figure to the left displays these relationships (the
dashed line represents the indirect path between the representamen and object).
</p>

<p>As an example, consider the notorious Microsoft Windows "Blue Screen of
Death" (the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=representamen" title="Look up: representamen" onclick="show_term('representamen', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">representamen</a>). When a user encounters this error code
screen, she may think that her computer has crashed (the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=interpretant" title="Look up: interpretant" onclick="show_term('interpretant', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">interpretant</a>),
and press Ctrl-Alt-Del to reboot the machine (the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=object" title="Look up: object" onclick="show_term('object', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">object</a>).</p>

<p>Especially important in this model of the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a> is the presence of the
<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=interpretant" title="Look up: interpretant" onclick="show_term('interpretant', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">interpretant</a> as an explicit component. Since the interpretant is
<em>created</em> by the observer, the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=object" title="Look up: object" onclick="show_term('object', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">object</a> is not given, but
<em>inferred</em>. This makes a sign's meaning highly dependent on context. With
two different interpretants, a single <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=representamen" title="Look up: representamen" onclick="show_term('representamen', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">representamen</a> (or <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=token" title="Look up: token" onclick="show_term('token', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">token</a>) can
have two different meanings. Similarly, a single object can be represented by
two different tokens. In both cases, we are dealing with two different signs.
</p>

<p>The figure below shows an example of a <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=representamen" title="Look up: representamen" onclick="show_term('representamen', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">representamen</a> with two
different <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=interpretant" title="Look up: interpretant" onclick="show_term('interpretant', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">interpretants</a>. Consider a user faced with
the common "Press any key to continue ..." prompt (the representamen). In one
case (i.e., one <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a>), this causes the user to think of the Enter key
(the interpretant), and results in her pressing that key (the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=object" title="Look up: object" onclick="show_term('object', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">object</a>). In
the other case, the same prompt causes the user (a computer novice) to think of
the nonexistent "Any" key (the interpretant). As can be expected, this results
in his futilely searching for the key (the object), and eventually leads to
confusion and/or frustration. (Though the particular situation illustrated in
this example is unlikely to occur, it still serves to highlight the necessity of
knowing your users when designing an interface.)</p>

<p class="sit-center"><img src="images/semiosis_example.jpg" width="616" height=
"486" alt="An example of a representamen with different interpretants" /></p>

<a name="classification"></a><h2>Peirce's classifications of signs</h2>

<p>Based upon how they convey meaning (i.e., the relationship between the
<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=representamen" title="Look up: representamen" onclick="show_term('representamen', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">representamen</a> and the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=object" title="Look up: object" onclick="show_term('object', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">object</a>), <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Peirce" title="Look up: Peirce" onclick="show_term('Peirce', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Peirce</a> classified
<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">signs</a> as <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=icon" title="Look up: icon" onclick="show_term('icon', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">icons</a>,
<a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=index" title="Look up: index" onclick="show_term('index', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">indices</a>, and <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=symbol" title="Look up: symbol" onclick="show_term('symbol', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">symbols</a> (note that like
"sign", these terms do not refer to their common usage).</p>

<ul>
  <li>
    <p>An <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=icon" title="Look up: icon" onclick="show_term('icon', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">icon</a> is a <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a> in which the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=representamen" title="Look up: representamen" onclick="show_term('representamen', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">representamen</a> is
    perceived as resembling (i.e., having some of the qualities of) the
    <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=object" title="Look up: object" onclick="show_term('object', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">object</a>. In <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Peirce" title="Look up: Peirce" onclick="show_term('Peirce', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Peirce's</a> words, such a sign "refers
    to the Object that it denotes merely by virtue of characters of its own ...
    such as a lead-pencil streak as representing a geometrical line."</p>

    <p><img src="images/trashcan.gif" width="32" height="32"
    alt="Trashcan" align="left" hspace="10" vspace="10" />For example,
    the trashcan "icon" (in computer-speak) is
    <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=iconic" title="Look up: iconic" onclick="show_term('iconic', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">iconic</a> of an actual trashcan, and the action of moving a file "icon"
    into the trashcan "icon" is iconic of the actual action of putting something
    in the trash. Also, the sound effects (usually) played when buddies sign on
    and off of a chat client are iconic of the actual sounds of a door opening
    and closing respectively.</p>

    <p>A <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=diagrammatic_icon" title="Look up: diagrammatic icon" onclick="show_term('diagrammatic_icon', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">diagrammatic icon</a> is a type of <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=icon" title="Look up: icon" onclick="show_term('icon', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">icon</a> that preserves the
    geometric properties of the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=object" title="Look up: object" onclick="show_term('object', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">object</a>; in this sense, the resemblance is
    not necessarily based on their similarity in appearance, but on the
    relationships between their parts. For example, the trashcan "icon"
    discussed previously would be better described as being
    <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=diagrammatic_iconic" title="Look up: diagrammatic iconic" onclick="show_term('diagrammatic_iconic', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">diagrammatic iconic</a>.</p>
  </li>
  <li style="clear: both;">
    <p>An <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=index" title="Look up: index" onclick="show_term('index', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">index</a> is a <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a> in which the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=representamen" title="Look up: representamen" onclick="show_term('representamen', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">representamen</a> is in
    some way (i.e., physically or causally) directly connected to the
    <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=object" title="Look up: object" onclick="show_term('object', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">object</a>. Unlike an <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=icon" title="Look up: icon" onclick="show_term('icon', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">icon</a>, an index has no significant
    resemblance to the object. Instead, there exists a law-like relationship
    between the representamen <i>x</i> and the object <i>y</i>: if <i>x</i>,
    there always or usually is a <i>y</i> (it is for this reason that unedited
    photographs and video&#8212;which are indexical of the effect of light on
    the film&#8212;are often admissible as evidence [<a href=
    "references.php#ref1">1</a>]).</p>

    <p><img src="images/diskette.gif" width="32" height="32"
    alt="Diskette" align="left" hspace="10" vspace="10" />For example, the
    earlier mentioned trashcan "icon" is
    <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=indexical" title="Look up: indexical" onclick="show_term('indexical', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">indexical</a> of the process of deletion; similarly, a diskette "icon" is
    indexical of the process of saving. The "Blue Screen of Death" is indexical
    of the computer having crashed. Also, a person's username and password are
    together indexical of that person (and hence can be used for
    authentication).</p>
  </li>
  <li style="clear: both;">
    <p>A <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=symbol" title="Look up: symbol" onclick="show_term('symbol', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">symbol</a> is a <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=sign" title="Look up: sign" onclick="show_term('sign', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">sign</a> in which the relationship between the
    <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=representamen" title="Look up: representamen" onclick="show_term('representamen', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">representamen</a> and the <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=object" title="Look up: object" onclick="show_term('object', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">object</a> is arbitrary or conventional
    (i.e., it must be learnt). According to <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=Peirce" title="Look up: Peirce" onclick="show_term('Peirce', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">Peirce</a>, such a sign "is
    constituted a sign merely or mainly by the fact that it is used and
    understood as such."
    </p>

    <p><img src="images/aim.gif" width="32" height="32" alt=
    "AIM" align="left" hspace="10" vspace="10" />For example, language is
    generally considered to be <a class="term" href="glossary.php?term=symbolic" title="Look up: symbolic" onclick="show_term('symbolic', event.screenX, event.screenY); return false;">symbolic</a>.
    Logos (such as AOL's Running Man) are symbolic of the corresponding company.
    Also, using colors (red, yellow, and green) to represent the quality of
    connection (poor, fair, and excellent respectively) in a network status
    "icon" is symbolic.</p>
  </li>
</ul>
<?php
/* Print page footer */
print_page_footer();
?>

