Authors:
| criterion | max | score |
| abstract and introduction informative about methods and results | 3 |
|
| clear and reproducible descriptions of algorithms | 4 |
|
| sensible design of variant methods |
|
|
| correct and efficient implementation of methods |
|
|
| clear, simple, sensible,
systematic designs for experiments |
4 |
|
| experiments that are sufficiently comprehensive | 3 |
|
| credible and useful experimental results |
|
|
| good presentation of results in tables and/or (preferred) graphics | 3 |
|
| appropriate evaluation of significance of comparisons
between results |
|
|
| clear, sensible discussion of all major results and
lessons
learned |
|
|
| logical organization and good technical prose style |
|
|
| correct spelling, grammar, formatting, and choice of words |
|
|
|
total
|
|