Title:
Author:
| criterion | max | score |
| good introductory background, motivation, and/or summary |
|
|
| information from three books combined appropriately |
|
|
| relevant information from additional sources used well | 3 | |
| fundamental concepts explained clearly and precisely |
|
|
| careful, rigorous arguments |
|
|
| appropriate integration of statistics, anecdotes, and logic |
|
|
| relevant use of detailed, accurate technical knowledge |
|
|
| cross-cultural and historical perspective |
|
|
| insightful observations and conclusions |
|
|
| coherent overall organization, flowing well |
|
|
| correct vocabulary and usage |
|
|
| appropriate prose style |
|
|
| correct spelling and grammar |
|
|
| appropriate formatting and presentation |
|
|
| citations in all necessary places with full bibliographic data |
|
|
|
total
|
|